Zaragoza · What to see

Carmen Gate

Puerta del Carmen

A neoclassical arch of three openings, standing alone on a traffic island, its ashlar riddled with impacts that nobody has ever wanted to repair. It is the last surviving gate of the Zaragoza circuit and the most eloquent monument to the Sieges of 1808 and 1809, when the city held out against two assaults by Napoleon's troops and was left practically destroyed.

Two sieges and a city laid waste

Zaragoza was not a fortress: it had an old circuit, without modern bastions, and a small garrison. When the French army arrived in 1808 it expected to take the place in days. Resistance was improvised as it went, with the civilian population fighting house by house, and the first siege was lifted after two months.

The second, between December 1808 and February 1809, was far worse. The French changed tactics and advanced by blowing up block after block with mines, while inside a typhus epidemic spread. By the time the city capitulated, tens of thousands had died, most of them civilians and from disease.

This gate was one of the hardest points of the fighting, and the bullet and shrapnel marks you see in the stone are from then. It was decided to keep them unrestored, and that decision turns the monument into a document rather than a commemoration.

A neoclassical arch turned into a scar

The gate had been built only a few decades before the Sieges, at the end of the eighteenth century, in the neoclassicism then dominant: three round-headed openings, pilasters, entablature and attic, all in stone and with a deliberate restraint.

That orderly, rational language contrasts violently with what happened to it afterwards, and that contrast is what makes the monument work: an Enlightenment triumphal arch turned into a surface for impacts. Go up close and run your hand over the ashlar on the side that faces the open country.

Of the several gates the circuit once had, this is the only one that survived the demolitions of the nineteenth century, when the walls were regarded as an obstacle to urban growth. Today it stands isolated on a traffic island with cars around it, which takes a good deal away from its effect.

Highlights

The impacts have not been repaired

The bullet and shrapnel marks of 1809 are still in the ashlar. It was decided to keep them unrestored.

The city was not a fortress

An old circuit, without modern bastions, and a small garrison. The French expected to take it in days.

The second siege was worse

The French advanced by blowing up block after block with mines while typhus spread inside.

It is the last one left

Of the several gates of the circuit, only this one survived the demolitions of the nineteenth century.

How it fits into your visit to Zaragoza

It stands on the paseo María Agustín, fifteen minutes on foot from the centre, on the natural way towards the Aljafería. It links well with that visit, going or coming back.

At the other end of the old town, the Plaza de los Sitios commemorates the same episode with a monument from the beginning of the twentieth century, and the basilica of Santa Engracia was also destroyed in those months. The three points tell the same story.

It is a five-minute stop, out in the open and free. Its interest is not architectural but documentary: it is the only place in the city where you can physically touch what happened in 1809.

Frequently asked questions

Who led that fierce resistance?

The soul of the defence was a young general, José de Palafox, captain general of Aragon, who refused again and again to surrender the city. They say that, when the French demanded capitulation, he answered with two words that have gone down in history: «guerra a cuchillo», war to the knife. And it was no bluff: they fought inch by inch, with women and friars lending a hand. That brutal stubbornness is what turned Zaragoza into a legend all over Europe.

And what did all that cost?

A very high price, the kind that is hard to imagine. In the second siege alone it is estimated that more than fifty thousand people died inside the city, and most did not fall to bullets, but to hunger and to the typhus that spread among so many people crammed together. When the French finally entered, in February 1809, they found a city half in ruins and strewn with the dead.

Discover Zaragoza and listen at your own pace

Carmen Gate is included in our tour La Aljafería and palatial Zaragoza.

Viavoy app

Other places in Zaragoza

Rincón de Goya

Zuda Tower

Zaragoza City Hall

Basilica of Our Lady of the Pillar

Basilica of Santa Engracia

Cathedral of the Saviour